A viral claim that Manchester City fans threw Phil Foden’s shirt back at him after the 3-1 defeat to Nottingham Forest has been disputed by people closer to the original footage.
As filmed from the stands at the City Ground, it referred to the aftermath of Forest’s win on Saturday, in which Jair Cunha and a Liam Delap brace secured the points and Rayan Cherki replied for City.
Foden’s shirt got thrown back to him. That’s so disrespectful. https://t.co/CzCyYHcIpN
— PAULO (@DPAULOJNRRR) November 8, 2026
It was City’s third consecutive league defeat, and Foden had entered as a late substitute.
It was claimed that Foden tried to hand his shirt to travelling supporters and that a fan immediately threw it back, interpreting the gesture as frustration after the result.
Shirt exchanges after matches usually signal appreciation, so a rejection would have been unusual and pointed.
However, from a fan account at the stadium, the video was “nabbed” and later deleted because “it was a scarf thrown on the pitch,” not Foden’s shirt.
Another comment called the account’s framing “cringy as fuck” and accused it of lying.
This suggests the viral narrative may rest on a misidentification of the object being thrown onto the pitch rather than a deliberate rejection of Foden’s jersey.
No mainstream match reports or official City coverage described any such shirt incident; the story remained confined to social media clips and fan-page posts.
Foden, a long-serving City academy product, has experienced fluctuating form and minutes amid competition for places.
Coming off the bench in a heavy away defeat fits a broader pattern of City’s recent struggles after a strong opening run.
Some fans treated the reported rejection as evidence of fan anger after successive losses.
Others pushed back, noting the scarf clarification or calling out the account for sensationalising ordinary post-match footage.
In short, the claim that City fans deliberately threw Foden’s shirt back doesn’t hold up against evidence from those who saw the original footage.